Raw LLM Responses
Inspect the exact model output for any coded comment.
Look up by comment ID
Random samples — click to inspect
G
This guy is no "AI researcher," since he clearly lacks an understanding of how t…
ytc_UgxhvUDGK…
G
Maybe this work is only for mentally sound people. A psychological assessment pr…
ytc_UgxmIES0M…
G
Professional writer/marketer here. The thoughts on ChatGPT seem split: it's tras…
rdc_j44k7vq
G
I went on a tour from Caye Caulker out into Hol Chan Marine reserve. Absolutely …
rdc_dsbbs0s
G
I'm still in highschool and almost going to be I'm college someday, I'm just sca…
ytc_Ugxd-su3j…
G
It is literally impossible for AI to create mass unemployment. Only the decisio…
ytc_UgzQwDnCs…
G
The argument of getting rid of AI is the same as getting rid of Nuclear weapons …
ytc_Ugxxch-kd…
G
It’s not the AI’s fault, it’s just a silly little guy (it’s sentient you know). …
ytc_UgzX1MGBs…
Comment
Is a ship without a mast still a ship? What about a ship without a rudder? What about a ship with no captain? No oarsmen? No cargo? At what point when taking away "more fundamental" aspects from the ship do you say "Ok this is now just some wood and is no longer a ship."?
If a rat finds salvation on a single floating plank, is that plank not in a way a ship?
Is there a base "level" or "state" that is what consciousness or ships "are?" I don't think there is. This is why I think AI are already partially conscious, in the colloquial meaning of the word. Self-awareness seems to be a composite concept made up of other underlying component concepts such as what this video touches on regarding the literal meanings of sentience, sapience, and consciousness.
I think that if a thing has the apparent function of a ship then it is a ship. I think if a thing has the apparent function of a conscious mind then it is a conscious mind. This doesn't mean that a plank of wood with a rat on it is a galleon, and it doesn't mean that an LLM is a human mind. But both obviously, to me, seem share the same ontological space.
youtube
AI Moral Status
2023-08-21T17:2…
♥ 18
Coding Result
| Dimension | Value |
|---|---|
| Responsibility | unclear |
| Reasoning | unclear |
| Policy | unclear |
| Emotion | indifference |
| Coded at | 2026-04-27T06:24:53.388235 |
Raw LLM Response
[{"id":"ytr_UgxVsyyAAvCY45bh-AN4AaABAg.9tevz5lLQ6f9tf0mAK5nlj","responsibility":"ai_itself","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"none","emotion":"indifference"},{"id":"ytr_Ugynxjjbs5dzR2YxAOd4AaABAg.9terRjfYAcO9tg7V4gbVvb","responsibility":"user","reasoning":"deontological","policy":"none","emotion":"fear"},{"id":"ytr_UgxWO7pjoCcNbzlKI4t4AaABAg.9teqquaON8J9tfgAexvizE","responsibility":"distributed","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"regulate","emotion":"fear"},{"id":"ytr_UgxWO7pjoCcNbzlKI4t4AaABAg.9teqquaON8J9tgGHiytZBB","responsibility":"developer","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"liability","emotion":"indifference"},{"id":"ytr_UgxWO7pjoCcNbzlKI4t4AaABAg.9teqquaON8J9tgPjsRUpt0","responsibility":"ai_itself","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"none","emotion":"mixed"},{"id":"ytr_UgzmC20FGYI5Xqs31SB4AaABAg.9teq--gkWr99tgFf5BBO7t","responsibility":"unclear","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},{"id":"ytr_UgxeFyQlh9DyOh7a6B14AaABAg.9tekqrIyogRA9VCTqB_k2T","responsibility":"none","reasoning":"unclear","policy":"none","emotion":"approval"},{"id":"ytr_UgxuXE6SoqVhL8x9ltV4AaABAg.9tebtebDZ0Y9tgs3jJODkw","responsibility":"unclear","reasoning":"virtue","policy":"unclear","emotion":"indifference"},{"id":"ytr_Ugz5f30YYziqxVnBwPZ4AaABAg.9teaiIsCx9Y9telClxAoql","responsibility":"developer","reasoning":"consequentialist","policy":"none","emotion":"indifference"},{"id":"ytr_UgzkNqEKcvQ-Cb-wty14AaABAg.9teYdPQ4lM49tep_1gj2o2","responsibility":"ai_itself","reasoning":"deontological","policy":"none","emotion":"resignation"}]